Neoseeker : Articles : Video : Game Accelerators : Gigabyte Radeon HD 3870 versus the 9600GT
Hardware Newsletter:
Email:

News Headlines
New Articles

Compare Prices

Motherboards
Abit
ASUS
Gigabyte
MSI
eVGA
Intel
Tyan
More...

Processors
AMD
Intel
More...

Memory
DDR
DDR2
DDR3
More...

Video Cards
ATI
eVGA
XFX
BFG
Sapphire
More...

search for lowest prices

send article   hardware newsletter   article comments (10)
Gigabyte Radeon HD 3870 versus the 9600GT - PAGE 2
Kevin Spiess - Wednesday, February 27th, 2008

While Neoseeker has reviewed a number of HD 3870 cards over the last few months, the good news has been that they have all been unique in their own way. The Gigabyte HD 3870 continues this trend as well, with the most obvious feature seperating it from the HD 3870 pack is its unique cooling solution. Gigabyte chose to go with Zalman do design their cooler. You are probably familiar with Zalman Tech -- they are a Korean company that has become renown for their effective cooler designs, and has been around since the late 20th century (--well, since 1999 anyways).

This time around Zalman has come up with a half-circle heat fin array, composed of aluminum and copper. While it may look a little less serious than some coolers we have seen recently (such as the one on VisionTek's HD 3870), this Zalman 2-ball bearing cooler proved effective in our testing. The fan ran at a high RPM, as well as being fairly quiet, even when manually set to run at 100%.

Left to right: VisionTek HD 3870, Gigabyte HD 3870, Asus HD 3870 TOP (close to reference board design)

As effective as the Zalman fan is, there are two faults to this cooling situation that are apparent: first off, many people have a preference for hot air being moved out off their case by a cooler; and secondly, the fan only blows a bit air over the Gigabyte HD 3870's memory, and their is no metal heatsink at all over this important region. While it is pretty much assured that this will not be a problem for regular operation, not having a heatsink over the memory is sure to hinder overclocking. 

The Gigabyte HD 3870 also features 'Ultra Durable 2 Technology', which can be seen as marketing catchphrase basically describing 'Higher Quality Components.' But this isn't to deride Gigabyte for choosing this name: the higher quality ferrite core chokes and capacitors are something to be proud, for sure. To what extent they improve performance should be seen in the benchmarks. 

Let's take a look at some numbers, shall we? The Gigabyte HD 3870 is not a factory-overclocked model -- and actually has a slower than average memory clock -- and can be attached to the following numbers, as reported by GPU-Z:

  Gigabyte HD 3870 9600GT (reference)

8800GT 512MB (reference)

8800GT 256MB (reference) HD 3870 (reference) HD 3850 (reference)
Stream Processors 320 64 112 112 320 320
Core Clock 776 650 600 600 775 668
Shader Clock   1625 1500 1500 775 668
Memory Clock 1890 1800 1800 1800 2250 1656
Memory Interface 256 bit 256 bit 256 bit 256 bit 256 bit 256 bit
Memory Type 512 MB GDDR3 512MB GDDR3 512MB GDDR3 256MB GDDR3 512MB GDDR4 256MB GDDR3
Memory Bandwidth (GB/s) 60.5 57.6  57.6 57.6 72.0 52.9
Texture Fillrate (billion/sec) 12.4 20.8 33.6 33.6 12.4 10.6
Fabrication Process 55nm 65nm 65nm 65nm 55nm 55nm

As you might have noticed as well, this is one of the few HD 3870 cards that has GDDR3 memory instead of GDDR4 memory. 

As will all HD 3870 cards, this current generation of from ATI supports DirectX 10.1, Shader Model 4.1, PCI-Express 2.0, HDMI audio, and has HDCP decryption ability for playing HD / Blu Ray DVDs. Also with the HD 3870 you get a Tessellation unit, and ATI's Universal Video Decoder.


Article Index

1.Introduction
2.Close look at the Gigabyte HD 3870
3.Power Usage & Overclocking
4.Box and Bundle
5.Benchmarking Setup
6.3DMark06
7.Unreal Tournament 3
8.Enemy Territory: Quake Wars
9.Call of Juarez DX10
10.Bioshock
11.World In Conflict
12.Crysis
13.In the end...

Submit our article to: diggDigg this! de.le.ciousdel.icio.us

Get updates when we publish new articles
Email Address:
(0.0635/d/nova)