User Reviews

Average User Score:
2.85/5.0
» Submit your own review

PS2  Who Says The 80's Are Dead? 4.2
0 comments
by SonicHero12
Sep 20, 2008
THE GOOD:
A chance to play along to the hits of the 80's
Bright, detailed visuals, from the crowd to the band itself
Some good songs, including such hits as We Got The Beat and I Ran(So Far Away)


THE BAD:
Basically a re-skin of Guitar Hero 2, with the same venues and the same characters, only in a bright neon tint
Rather haphazard song selection
Charging full price for less content(No bonus songs, no videos/unlockables other than guitars and outfits, albeit the guitars are all the same as Guitar Hero 2)

SUMMARY:
Let me say this: I know in my heart that this is a rather below-average game, but since it's Guitar Hero, and since it's still fun to play, I love it for some reason.

For those of you who aren't familiar with it, this is how Guitar Hero's gameplay works: you use a guitar-shaped controller with five "fret" buttons(although you only use all five in hard and expert mode). You must hold down the fret button that corresponds to the note on the screen and press the "strum" bar up or down to play the note. You can also gain "Star Power"(A power-up which increases your multiplier), which can be activated tilting the guitar or pressing the "select" button. On the guitar is also a whammy bar, to modify the sound of long notes and to extract star power from long notes.

Obviously, this game a chance to rock to the hits of the 80's, from Quiet Riot's Metal Health to Extreme's Play With Me. The tracks are well laid-out, and fun to play as usual. The only real problem I have with the song list are songs themselves. How many people remember Faster Pussycat, much less the song Bathroom Wall? Where is the Journey? Boston? Aerosmith? It seems to me that if Harmonix wanted to make this a true addition to the Guitar Hero library, they would have added songs that truly embodied what was so great about the 80's: the music. I will say this, there are some decent songs that were wildly popular in the hair spray days, such as Scandal's The Warrior, Twisted Sister's I Wanna Rock, and Fock of Seagull's I Ran(So Far Away). As an added bonus, all the songs I just listed are the master tracks, not covers(However, like Guitar Hero 2, most of the other songs are covers. They are fairly well-done, though, with the only exception being The Dead Kennedy's Police Truck. The master contains a fair amount of swearing, so WaveGroup's cover makes for some odd lyrics, as they substituted new lines for less child-friendly lines).

The song list aside, my second major problem with this game is the fact that it is, plain and simple, a re-skin of Guitar Hero 2. The venues are the same. The characters are the same. The guitars are the same. Even the opening intro is the same. Everything is the same except for the fact that everything is tinted neon to give it an 80's-ish look (A couple things I found amusing are that the Reaper is wearing 3-D glasses and in the intro the Harmonix and Activision logo are pixelated with an 80's look) The fact that everything is the same as the last game takes away from the excitement, because if you've already play Guitar Hero 2 you know what's coming up next. The character's wear 80's based outfits and sport 80's hair(Pandora's hair actually made me laugh), and some outfits can be unlocked in the store to complement the character's default clothes. Even though the graphics are a repeat of Guitar Hero 2, they are still bright and exaggerant and seem to jump off the screen. I just wish that they would fix the drummer. He never moves from his snare and high hat, which really saps what little realism that is in Guitar Hero.

My third gripe is about the difficulty. It is extremely easy, with some of the final tier choices being songs that wouldn't be out of place in the opening set of Guitar Hero 2(Police Truck? Really?). But the thing that really threw me off is, as easy as the game was, the final song(Play With Me by Extreme) is unbelievably difficult, rivalling the difficulty of Free Bird, possibly being harder. It took me a while to beat that song. Lastly, this installment does not come with a guitar controller, so unfortunately if you are a beginner or you don't own any other Guitar Hero titles, you are out of luck.

So, in summary, if you are a hardcore fan of the Guitar Hero series, such as I am, pick this up. If you aren't very committed, leave this one alone. It one won't prove of much replay value to you. And if you are a beginner, this really isn't the place to start. Pick up Guitar Hero 1 or 2. But for the rest of you virtual guitar virtuosos, this is definitely a worthy addition to your Guitar Hero library.

0 out of 0 people found this review helpful.Did you find this review helpful? YES  NO


PS2  Guitar Hero - The Complete Waste of Time Edition 1.5
0 comments
by Johnny_G
from Toronto, ON, Canada
Jul 29, 2007
THE GOOD:
I remember when the first Guitar Hero came out. It didn't really interest me all that much but my girlfriend wanted it so I got it for her birthday. It didn't take long before I was hooked too. That first Guitar Hero game had a lot of charm - it practically radiated off the screen. You knew while playing that Red Octane was a small company and that they'd poured everything they had into their work. It showed in almost every facet. The game wasn't polish perfect but it had a lot of heart. It's still my favourite of the three.

Guitar Hero II was a logical purchase given my fondness for the first game and while it delivered, it wasn't as great. It wasn't a bad game but it didn't really live up to the spirit of the first. The songs weren't as well chosen; the note layout was often hard for the sake of hard. By this I mean that you could actually tell when the notes didn't match the actual guitar riffs, and were just thrown out to try and psyche people out. I feel a lot of these problems could be traced to a single source - Activision. Allow me to explain.

Activision had a hand in distributing the first game, but production and development was entirely handled by Red Octane. At that time there was no certainty that this fringe game with an expensive peripheral would take off... but it did. And when that happened Activision execs saw dollar signs flash before their eyes. And the soul of the first game was lost to profiteering. Guitar Hero II still delivered, yes... but at a lower level. And then came Guitar Hero 80's Edition, and I'm sorry to say that there is absolutely nothing redeeming about this game.

THE BAD:
My biggest problem with this game is that it's a money-grab by Activision, pure and simple. The first two Guitar Hero games featured 8 sets of 5 popular songs (that's 40), plus about 20 underground songs. That brought the set list to about 60 or so. Guitar Hero 80's edition offers a grand total of 30 "hit" songs, with no underground material included. The first game had a total of seven characters. I believe the second one had nine. This game has six. The sets and backdrops are reused from the second game. The menu and loading screens are ported straight from Guitar Hero II. And the list goes on....

The effort put into the actual tracks also appears quite minimal. In previous games the cover bands that performed the songs weren't always spectacular - Heart Shaped Box was particularly terrible, for example. But it was NOTHING like this. EVERY cover in this game is completely terrible. Some, such as Holy Diver by Dio, are utterly laughable. I wouldn't be surprised if the so-called cover bands were just the friends and family of the developers, as it really is that bad.

I think there's a logical explanation for all of this - 80's Edition is intended as an expansion of Guitar Hero II, something to tide fans over before the third official installment drops later this year. And that unto itself is fine; I would expect such a game to feel a bit rushed and to recycle some material. I have no problem with that at all... provided the title retails for 29.99 or less. 80's Edition, on the other hand, sells at full price. FULL PRICE. And believe me, you do not get what you pay for.

SUMMARY:
As you can probably tell, I just completed this game. It's also worth noting that I bought it less then six hours ago. And I'm finished, on Hard Mode, and that's about all the effort I'm willing to put in. If I'm lucky I can trade this thing back in for forty bucks or something, before the rest of the world figures out what a pile of garbage this is.

If you're not a fan of Guitar Hero, don't even bother touching this one. If you are a fan, please, do yourself a favour and just rent it. Or, failing that, borrow it from some poor soul like me who has wasted their money. Save your cash for something else. I promise you that you can get through the entire game in less than 5 hours if you have any degree of skill at all. And I also can assure you that the replay value of the previous games does not exist here. These songs are BAD - they are poorly chosen and poorly performed. This is by far the worst installment in the series and, quite honestly, Red Octane and Activision should be utterly ashamed of themselves.

2 out of 4 people found this review helpful.Did you find this review helpful? YES  NO


Lowest Prices



Series
(0.0682/d/nova)