Computer HardwareXbox GamesGameCubePlaystation 2PSOnePC/Windows GamesGameboy AdvanceDreamcastNintendo 64Gameboy ColorNintendo DSSony PSPXbox 360Nintendo Wii GamesPS3 Games

Neoseeker Forums » Playstation Games » RPG » The Legend of Dragoon » [Theory] Claire

The Legend of Dragoon Forum

profile  pro reviews  user reviews  cheats  FAQs/Guides  screens  discussion board  

REPLY TO THIS THREAD   START NEW THREAD
Options: Print   subscribe   remove   send to friend   PM this thread to a friendNeoPM
Topic: [Theory] Claire
Avalith
Feb 05, 08 at 1:28pm
[Theory] Claire

I've only played Legend of Dragoon a couple of times with this weekend being my most recent playthrough, so this has probably already been confirmed or disproved, but here goes. Also, this will have quite a few potential spoilers, so if you're still playing the game and haven't beaten it before, you've been warned.

Is it just me, or is Haschel really Dart's grandfather? It may just be a crazy coincidence since they look nothing alike, but here's the evidence that supports this:

  • Disc 2: When you first enter Fletz in Tiberoa, the group notices that the bridge you cross going to the bar from the entrance to the city is named Claire Bridge. This is the first time you hear Dart mention the name of his mother, which is also Claire. Haschel also mentions that it's the name of his runaway daughter that he's been looking for for 20 years. This spurs a discussion among the group about this theory, which they disprove based on the fact that the two look nothing alike.
  • Disc 3: When you spend the night at the mayor's house in Furni in Mille Sesau before going off into Evergreen Forest to handle Kamuy, Haschel overhears Shana singing a lullaby to Fa and reflects on a memory where he found Claire singing the same lullaby and she said she was dedicating it to her future child. Haschel then asks Shana where she learned it, to which she responds that Dart used to sing it to her all the time when she was little.
  • Disc 4: This is what could easily prove my theory. When you're in the Moon That Never Sets, you chase Claire for a bit before Haschel faces her one on one. When Dart scares her away by approaching her, Haschel says that she doesn't know about him yet and then goes off to face her alone.
Feel free to disprove this or find other supporting evidence either in the game or in other official sources if you can.



-------------------
ZL: it's been a while since I got any.
quote   quick quote   edit   quick edit   del  report
Members, log in or register to remove these ads.
DivineDragoon23
To Victory!!!!!
forum raider



DivineDragoon23's profileEmail DivineDragoon23NeoPM DivineDragoon23
total posts: 3068
since: Mar 2006
Feb 05, 08 at 3:32pm
re: [Theory] Claire

I've pretty much got the biggest point to disprove this:

HASCHEL IS ASIAN. DART IS NOT.

And Zeke (I think that's his name) Is Dart's father. This has been proven many times. Now remember that Zeke has been alive since the Dragon Campaign (11 000 years), so he can't be the son of Haschel. Lastly, Haschel's daughter ran away 20 years earlier. But Dart is 21 in the game, so he would have been 1 year old when she "dipped" from Haschel's place. I didnt mean to completely bash your theory though. At times, I thought it might be possible.

That and the fact I just came up with this stuff now. XD



-------------------
quote   quick quote   edit   quick edit   del  report
Hard_Rocker
submission happy



Hard_Rocker's profileEmail Hard_RockerNeoPM Hard_Rocker
total posts: 111
since: Mar 2005
Feb 05, 08 at 4:53pm
re: [Theory] Claire

Actually Dart'd dad's name is Zeig... You were close.



-------------------
I find you very condesending...
quote   quick quote   edit   quick edit   del  report
Roxas Rules
I just punched Sarcasm in the face.
s-e-e-k-e-r



Roxas Rules's profileNeoPM Roxas Rules
total posts: 1911
since: Aug 2007
Feb 05, 08 at 9:47pm
re: [Theory] Claire

quote Hard_Rocker
Actually Dart'd dad's name is Zeig... You were close.
Actually, It's Zieg. You were close too.



-------------------

Better than nothing.

quote   quick quote   edit   quick edit   del  report
Wolfwood824
SPOOOOOOOOON!!!
true seeker (2K Remix)



Wolfwood824's profileNeoPM Wolfwood824
total posts: 2090
since: Nov 2004
Feb 06, 08 at 9:36am
re: [Theory] Claire

quote DivineDragoon23
I've pretty much got the biggest point to disprove this:

HASCHEL IS ASIAN. DART IS NOT.
And? Dart obviously gets his looks (and his outfit =P) from his father.

quote DivineDragoon23
And Zeke (I think that's his name) Is Dart's father. This has been proven many times. Now remember that Zeke has been alive since the Dragon Campaign (11 000 years), so he can't be the son of Haschel.
He's Claire's father, not Zieg's. Most people have two sets of grandparents, you know. =P

quote DivineDragoon23
Lastly, Haschel's daughter ran away 20 years earlier. But Dart is 21 in the game, so he would have been 1 year old when she "dipped" from Haschel's place.
20 years is likely just an approximation (much like how I doubt the Dragon Campaign ended exactly 11,000 years ago).



-------------------
quote Zero and X
I like the sensation of having two big bars.
quote   quick quote   edit   quick edit   del  report
Avalith
Feb 06, 08 at 10:56am
re: [Theory] Claire

Plus, there's nothing that says that Claire and Zieg didn't meet before she left Rouge if this theory is actually correct, and for all we know, she could have left 24 or 25 years prior to the events in the game.

And also, Dart is actually 23 in the game. The Black Monster destroyed Neet 18 years before the game started, and if you pay attention, you'll learn that Dart was 5 at the time of the attack. 18 + 5 = 23.



-------------------
ZL: it's been a while since I got any.
quote   quick quote   edit   quick edit   del  report
DivineDragoon23
To Victory!!!!!
forum raider



DivineDragoon23's profileEmail DivineDragoon23NeoPM DivineDragoon23
total posts: 3068
since: Mar 2006
Feb 06, 08 at 12:24pm
re: [Theory] Claire

Shit! The manual lied to me! It lists Dart as 21 years old in the manual!!!

And I'm pretty sure Haschel wouldn't make an "approximation" about how long ago it was Claire ran away. It's a little more important than that.



-------------------
quote   quick quote   edit   quick edit   del  report
Avalith
Feb 06, 08 at 1:41pm
re: [Theory] Claire

quote DivineDragoon23
Shit! The manual lied to me! It lists Dart as 21 years old in the manual!!!
Just another one of the typos in the game.



-------------------
ZL: it's been a while since I got any.
quote   quick quote   edit   quick edit   del  report
Hard_Rocker
submission happy



Hard_Rocker's profileEmail Hard_RockerNeoPM Hard_Rocker
total posts: 111
since: Mar 2005
Feb 07, 08 at 11:32am
re: [Theory] Claire

quote Roxas Rules
quote Hard_Rocker
Actually Dart'd dad's name is Zeig... You were close.
Actually, It's Zieg. You were close too.
Oops:D that's right...



-------------------
I find you very condesending...
quote   quick quote   edit   quick edit   del  report
Ziekara
forum junky

Ziekara's profile
total posts: 86
since: Nov 2005
Feb 25, 08 at 8:14pm
re: [Theory] Claire

quote DivineDragoon23
Shit! The manual lied to me! It lists Dart as 21 years old in the manual!!!

And I'm pretty sure Haschel wouldn't make an "approximation" about how long ago it was Claire ran away. It's a little more important than that.

Actually, according to what Haschel says the first time he mentions his daughter in Lohan, he says she's been LOOKING for her for 20 years, not that she ran away 20 years go. It could be possible that he waited several years for her to return on her own before he set out looking for her.



-------------------
I may be a fallen angel, but even fallen angel's were divine once
quote   quick quote   edit   quick edit   del  report
DivineDragoon23
To Victory!!!!!
forum raider



DivineDragoon23's profileEmail DivineDragoon23NeoPM DivineDragoon23
total posts: 3068
since: Mar 2006
Feb 26, 08 at 3:25pm
re: [Theory] Claire

I really don't think he would do that. Would you wait several years for your child to come home? IT reminds me of the simpsons, specifically Nelson's dad. He went out to get a pack of smokes, and never came back. Nelson still thought he was out buying that pack of smokes for over 5 years. XD

And one more thing, Dart used to train under Haschel. And Dart already knew about how he was searching for his daughter. Don't you think that they would have come up to the conclusion that Dart's mom and Haschel's daughter are one and the same (if it was true)?

Haschel: I'm searching for my daughter, Claire, who ran away some time ago.

Dart: My mom's name is Claire, too.

Haschel: Interesting.

Dart: OH SHI--

*heads explode*



-------------------
quote   quick quote   edit   quick edit   del  report
Avalith
Feb 26, 08 at 8:44pm
re: [Theory] Claire

quote DivineDragoon23
Don't you think that they would have come up to the conclusion that Dart's mom and Haschel's daughter are one and the same (if it was true)?
Given how slow Dart was to catch on with Shana, I doubt it. The strongest evidence in the game that actually supports this is in the Moon on Disc 4 where Haschel says that Claire doesn't know about Dart yet. My question is: Why else would he add the word yet in with his statement if there was no connection between them?



-------------------
ZL: it's been a while since I got any.
quote   quick quote   edit   quick edit   del  report
Ziekara
forum junky

Ziekara's profile
total posts: 86
since: Nov 2005
Feb 27, 08 at 4:37am
re: [Theory] Claire

quote Avalith
quote DivineDragoon23
Don't you think that they would have come up to the conclusion that Dart's mom and Haschel's daughter are one and the same (if it was true)?
Given how slow Dart was to catch on with Shana, I doubt it. The strongest evidence in the game that actually supports this is in the Moon on Disc 4 where Haschel says that Claire doesn't know about Dart yet. My question is: Why else would he add the word yet in with his statement if there was no connection between them?
Agreed. I think they make it pretty obvious, without actually coming out and saying it, that they are related. Plus, it's clear from the scene in Fletz that Dart and Haschel never discussed Claire's name until that moment, since the scene you just described (minus the head exploding) is actually exactly what happened. They never really say how long the two of them traveled together, they only mention that they met before 4 years ago. Maybe it wasn't long enough to really go into detail...or maybe it's just a game and the writers felt like keeping it a secret until that moment XD



-------------------
I may be a fallen angel, but even fallen angel's were divine once
quote   quick quote   edit   quick edit   del  report
draconic_girl
I really don't like lil bros
s-e-e-k-e-r



draconic_girl's profiledraconic_girl's neohome
total posts: 1730
since: Apr 2006
Mar 07, 08 at 7:44pm
re: [Theory] Claire

It's obvious that he is Dart's grandfather. If he wasn't they wouldn't even bother to give hints and yada yada about the similarities between dart's mom and Haschel's daughter. Books, video games, and movies NEVER/RARELY waste space on uneccessary info. The rarely is for those who like to jabber longer than the rest and those forms of entertainment are normally full of too much detail for one to process and actually enjoy.

Also the look factor, well Dart takes after his dad. I'm a female clone of my dad and I don't look a thing like my grandparents on my mom's side....Actually now that i think about it none of my family looks similar...oh well



-------------------
quote   quick quote   edit   quick edit   del  report
DivineDragoon23
To Victory!!!!!
forum raider



DivineDragoon23's profileEmail DivineDragoon23NeoPM DivineDragoon23
total posts: 3068
since: Mar 2006
Mar 07, 08 at 7:49pm
re: [Theory] Claire

But...Haschel is asian (meaning Claire is too). Dart has nothing asian about him. Is everyone in your family of the same culture? If not, do you posses any features of their race? I know a dude where I work who's mom is asian, but father is white. Everything about him looks white, except for his eyes. Let's just say he's used to widescreen TV. XD



-------------------
quote   quick quote   edit   quick edit   del  report
[All dates in (PT) time]Threads List   « Next Newest   Next Oldest »
REPLY TO THIS THREAD   START A NEW THREAD


search:
Neoseeker Forums » Playstation Games » RPG » The Legend of Dragoon » [Theory] Claire



Jump to another forum:

Powered by neoforums v0.9.4 (equilibrium)
Copyright Neo Era Media, Inc. 1999-2008

neoseeker forum community
Neoseeker.com   |   Forum Rules   |   Forum FAQ   |   Neoseeker Terms of Use   |   Supermods On Duty [ server id: nova ··· elapsed: 0.1727769375]
Affiliated sites:   GameGrep - Football Manager Wiki - Halo Wiki - MGS Wiki - GTA Wiki - Smackdown Wiki - Zelda Wiki - PS2seeker - Xbox seeker - GC seeker - DEVPEN - GFXcess