Zelda needs to be lower

Peach needs to be lowered

Sheik needs to be higher

Marth needs to be lower

Fox/Falco need to be higher (lulz!)

Jigglypuff needs to be lower

Pikachu needs to be lower

Roy needs to be higher

Samus needs to be higher

Luigi needs to be higher

Donkey Kong needs to be lower

Yoshi needs to be lower

pichu you did this to me on the last page. i guess you just dont get it.

this thread is what your first impressions of the tier list were when you first saw it. go read the first post.

stop arguing with people about what they thought at the time was true, when theyve most likely changed their view now.

Yoshi's dtilt at the ledge is disgustingness incarnate

not to mention fumi

he should be mid tier, along with Link and Luigi

Peach should have her own tier directly below Marth and Sheik's, but directly above CF's

btw these are my thoughts at this very moment.

quote Paraplegic Munki

Peach should have her own tier directly below Marth and Sheik's, but directly above CF's

What would be the point?

I play her intensively so I tend to analyze her more closely than other characters.

The point would be to show players that not only is she severely disadvantaged against her high tier compadres, Peach players don't do nearly as well as Sheik and Marth players in tournaments overall.

Her matchups against the rest of the characters in the game isn't so immaculate either. She goes even against too many mid tier characters and even has a bad matchup against a low tier.

But she's a hell of a lot better overall than all the mid tiers, and actually has a realistic possibility of winning a large pro tournament, unlike Falcon and all those underneath him (unless you're ChuDat). And her best asset has to be the fact that she has a slight advantage against a top tier character.

I mean, I know it would look weird, but she's seriously too bad for high tier and too good for mid tier.

Bottom of high tier is perfect for her.

Straggling along at the bottom of a tier in a position she didn't earn is about as perfect for her as the republican party is perfect for a poor, gay, atheist, non-white college student.

this is your personal definition and justification of the tier list, which is highly arbitrary when considering distinctions, and does not require that level of precision.

Bottom of top tier is fine.

Fine bottom of the high tier is fine. No need to get all snooty.

quote duran1

Bottom of top tier is fine.

heyyy wait a minute i see what u did there

This message was edited by Paraplegic Munki on Oct 06 2008.

Maybe all the characters should have their own group. >_>

ive actually heard your opinion before munki, almost exactly the same arguement and reasoning. so just to let you guys know, hes not alone (or hes just copying someone elses opinion >__>).

i sort of agree, she is too low for high tier and too high for mid tier, its true imo. but that can be said of almost all characters on the edge of tiers, theres always debates to move them up or down from where they are.

bottom of high is fine.

"Snooty" is a fantastic adjective.

Actually, no that's only my opinion. I don't really hear too many people talk about peach all that often. I had no idea I wasn't alone in my reasoning.

Fantastic is almost as fantastic as snooty.

well i think that at least Zelda has to bemuch lower, aslo Fox , falco and Mewtwo, why there is a simple reason Hunters like THOSE characters in particular overall Sheik.