Computer HardwareXbox GamesGameCubePlaystation 2PSOnePC/Windows GamesGameboy AdvanceDreamcastNintendo 64Gameboy ColorNintendo DSSony PSPXbox 360Nintendo Wii GamesPS3 Games

All Family Guy Forums
Neoseeker Forums » Movies » Television » Family Guy Volume 3 (Season 4) » Did Family Guy Go Too Far?

REPLY TO THIS THREAD   START NEW THREAD
| Sharemore
Options: Print   subscribe   remove   PM this thread to a friendNeoPM  
subscribe to thread Topic: Did Family Guy Go Too Far?
Sonecor
That's inappropriate.
Resident Neo



Sonecor's profileNeoPM Sonecor
since: Aug 2002
Sep 05, 05 at 4:36am
Did Family Guy Go Too Far?

According to The Advocate Magine, a scene in The Cleveland-Loretta Quagmire, which first aired on June 12th, 2005, has offended many AIDS groups. In the scene, Peter tells Cleveland that is wife Loretta cheated on him because he has a great talent of breaking bad news to people.

As usual, the scene then flashbacked to Peter with 3 others singing a song about AIDS like a Barbershop Quartet to a young man (who has the stereotypical "gay" goatee).

The lyrics are:

Peter: You have AIDS.
Quartet: Yes, you have AIDS.
Peter: I hate to tell you, boy, you have AIDS.
Quartet: You got the AIDS.
Peter: You may have caught it when you stuck that filthy needle in here.
Quartet: Or maybe all that unprotected sex which we hear.
Peter: It isn't clear
Quartet But what we're certain of is that you have AIDS.
Peter:Yes, you have AIDS. Not HIV
Quartet: But full-blown AIDS.
Be sure that you see that this is not HIV, but full blown AIDS.
Not HIV, but full-blown AIDS.
Barbershop Quarter Man: I'm sorry, I wish it was something less serious
Quartet: But it's AIDS. You've got the AIDS.

The FOX Television Network said that viewers of Family Guy should expect the shocking and sometimes "tasteless" humor. They argued that the point was to show how bad Peter was at breaking news to people, not to make fun or offend anyone with the horrible disease.

Fox spokesman Steven Melnick said, "Over the years, Family Guy has skewered virtually every ethnic, religious, and social group. The audience that tunes into this series is well-aware of what to expect from the show: a subversive and sometimes shocking comedic view that occasionally skirts the borders of appropriateness. This scene is not a joke about HIV but rather Peter's ignorance and inability to convey bad news. Given the nature of this series as well as the well-established cluelessness of this particular character, the scene, while certainly abrasive, is not beyond the expectation of the Family Guy audience."

Craig E. Thompson, the executive director of an AIDS project in Los Angeles said that the scene should be "socially unacceptable" to watch. He said that the scene was just as funny as singing about someone with cancer. He also said that the scene disgraces AIDS and "reinforces homiphoiba."

Gene Copello, an AIDS Institute Director said that Family Guy acted irresponsibly by airing the scene. He said FOX should make an immediate apology to all the people living with HIV or AIDS. "There is nothing comical about a person lying in a hospital bed dying of AIDS or any other disease."

Source: Here

This information came from a NeoPortal
quote   quick quote   edit   quick edit   del  searchposts in thread  report
Sonecor
That's inappropriate.
Resident Neo



Sonecor's profileNeoPM Sonecor
since: Aug 2002
Sep 05, 05 at 4:36am
Did Family Guy Go Too Far?

So, what do you think? Should Family Guy not have aired that scene. I personally, thought it was funny but then again I'd probably feel much differently if I did have HIV or AIDS.

quote   quick quote   edit   quick edit   del  searchposts in thread  report
Dudeguy
ROCK - ROBOT ROCK
Relentless



Dudeguy's profileNeoPM Dudeguy
total posts: 9590
since: Nov 2003
Sep 05, 05 at 5:31am
re: Did Family Guy Go Too Far?

I found the scene humourous, but at the same time I was thinking that they might have gone overboard with this one. AIDS has killed millions of people and continues to do so, it's more than just stereotypes and isn't a laughing matter, like in the Wish Upon a Weinstein episode, so I can see how people could have been offended.


-------------------
"A great book should leave you with many experiences, and slightly exhausted.
You should live several lives while reading it."

-- William Stryon
Books and Literature Forum

quote   quick quote   edit   quick edit   del  searchposts in thread  report
Krunal
Sep 05, 05 at 11:53pm
re: Did Family Guy Go Too Far?

I personally don't think that it was a "major" thing, I mean I can see how people can get upset, but if you've seen the various episodes of Family Guy, you can see that its been MADE to take the piss out of various different things, and it just so happened that that day, it was that particular disease.


-------------------
quote   quick quote   edit   quick edit   del  searchposts in thread  report
Darknet
Get out of my Sanctum Solarium!
(moderator)

Loungin'
Sports



Darknet's profileBlogged: Go to hell, Ubisoft [Rant] [Dec 16 1:38 am]Darknet's gallery (3 images)
total posts: 25608
since: Aug 2002
Sep 06, 05 at 1:52am
re: Did Family Guy Go Too Far?

If I found anything, is if all you can do is be sad about something: laugh at it.



-------------------
quote   quick quote   edit   quick edit   del  searchposts in thread  report
Mario_Luigi
Slow things down or speed them up...
true seeker



Mario_Luigi's profile
total posts: 1073
since: Dec 2004
Sep 06, 05 at 2:37am
re: Did Family Guy Go Too Far?

I dont think it went to far.
I mean South Parks done alot worse,so the worst these people can do is what?Stop watching?



-------------------
quote   quick quote   edit   quick edit   del  searchposts in thread  report
Darknet
Get out of my Sanctum Solarium!
(moderator)

Loungin'
Sports



Darknet's profileBlogged: Go to hell, Ubisoft [Rant] [Dec 16 1:38 am]Darknet's gallery (3 images)
total posts: 25608
since: Aug 2002
Sep 06, 05 at 2:45am
re: Did Family Guy Go Too Far?

May we forget Team America's "Everyone Has AIDs" song?



-------------------
quote   quick quote   edit   quick edit   del  searchposts in thread  report
Mario_Luigi
Slow things down or speed them up...
true seeker



Mario_Luigi's profile
total posts: 1073
since: Dec 2004
Sep 06, 05 at 3:33am
re: Did Family Guy Go Too Far?

Really other things have gone alot farther then Family Guy



-------------------
quote   quick quote   edit   quick edit   del  searchposts in thread  report
SimpleBurden
Resident Neo



SimpleBurden's profileNeoPM SimpleBurdenSimpleBurden's Fan Art!
since: Jun 2005
Sep 11, 05 at 7:59pm
re: Did Family Guy Go Too Far?

I love that song! If ppl were afended by that, they then shouldent watch Family Guy

quote   quick quote   edit   quick edit   del  searchposts in thread  report
The Butcher
GET DOWN THEM STAIR YOU SHLAG!
Seeketh Maximus



The Butcher's profileThe Butcher's neohomeNeoPM The Butcher
since: Nov 2002
Sep 11, 05 at 8:28pm
re: Did Family Guy Go Too Far?

quote Darknet
May we forget Team America's "Everyone Has AIDs" song?
and that was 20 times worse.

its just people blowing hot air, it really annoys me, soon itll turn into BAN FAMILY GUY FOR SAYING AIDS!


-------------------

COME JOIN THE DISCUSSION, SHLAGS!
quote   quick quote   edit   quick edit   del  searchposts in thread  report
Spyrofiro
Resident Neo



Spyrofiro's profileSpyrofiro's neohomeNeoPM Spyrofiro
since: Dec 2003
Sep 11, 05 at 8:30pm
re: Did Family Guy Go Too Far?

I don't think it went to far. Though again unless you really have aids you can't tell how bad it is. You can think its not bad but if you actually have it it can seem much worse.

quote   quick quote   edit   quick edit   del  searchposts in thread  report
gameboy613
.________.
Still Seekin'



gameboy613's profilegameboy613's neohomeNeoPM gameboy613
since: Jul 2005
Sep 11, 05 at 9:24pm
re: Did Family Guy Go Too Far?

I also don't think that Family Guy went too far. If that was going too far then there should be hundreds of other things for Fox to apologize for that were way worse than that.



-------------------


quote   quick quote   edit   quick edit   del  searchposts in thread  report
7 Dragon
The Rebirth
Seeketh Maximus



7 Dragon's profileNeoPM 7 Dragon
total posts: 5423
since: Sep 2002
Sep 11, 05 at 10:56pm
re: Did Family Guy Go Too Far?

quote spyrofiro
I don't think it went to far. Though again unless you really have aids you can't tell how bad it is. You can think its not bad but if you actually have it it can seem much worse.
Right.

And it's only a cartoon. not a Puplic Service annoucement bishes. Get real. Team America's song was 20 times worse as stated before. But If I had HIV or AIDS, I'd really think this over differently, allthough I've never seen the episode itself, I've seen the song online, but have no idea what the source was.
quote   quick quote   edit   quick edit   del  searchposts in thread  report
SimpleBurden
Resident Neo



SimpleBurden's profileNeoPM SimpleBurdenSimpleBurden's Fan Art!
since: Jun 2005
Sep 12, 05 at 2:56am
re: Did Family Guy Go Too Far?

Angrys me really... I hate how ppl always find something bad about your favorite shows

quote   quick quote   edit   quick edit   del  searchposts in thread  report
SHOT CALLER
Its Show-Time!
true seeker (2K Remix)



SHOT CALLER's profile
total posts: 2153
since: Dec 2004
Sep 28, 05 at 10:14pm
re: Did Family Guy Go Too Far?

quote Sonecor
According to The Advocate Magine, a scene in The Cleveland-Loretta Quagmire, which first aired on June 12th, 2005, has offended many AIDS groups. In the scene, Peter tells Cleveland that is wife Loretta cheated on him because he has a great talent of breaking bad news to people.

As usual, the scene then flashbacked to Peter with 3 others singing a song about AIDS like a Barbershop Quartet to a young man (who has the stereotypical "gay" goatee).

The lyrics are:

Peter: You have AIDS.
Quartet: Yes, you have AIDS.
Peter: I hate to tell you, boy, you have AIDS.
Quartet: You got the AIDS.
Peter: You may have caught it when you stuck that filthy needle in here.
Quartet: Or maybe all that unprotected sex which we hear.
Peter: It isn't clear
Quartet But what we're certain of is that you have AIDS.
Peter:Yes, you have AIDS. Not HIV
Quartet: But full-blown AIDS.
Be sure that you see that this is not HIV, but full blown AIDS.
Not HIV, but full-blown AIDS.
Barbershop Quarter Man: I'm sorry, I wish it was something less serious
Quartet: But it's AIDS. You've got the AIDS.

The FOX Television Network said that viewers of Family Guy should expect the shocking and sometimes "tasteless" humor. They argued that the point was to show how bad Peter was at breaking news to people, not to make fun or offend anyone with the horrible disease.

Fox spokesman Steven Melnick said, "Over the years, Family Guy has skewered virtually every ethnic, religious, and social group. The audience that tunes into this series is well-aware of what to expect from the show: a subversive and sometimes shocking comedic view that occasionally skirts the borders of appropriateness. This scene is not a joke about HIV but rather Peter's ignorance and inability to convey bad news. Given the nature of this series as well as the well-established cluelessness of this particular character, the scene, while certainly abrasive, is not beyond the expectation of the Family Guy audience."

Craig E. Thompson, the executive director of an AIDS project in Los Angeles said that the scene should be "socially unacceptable" to watch. He said that the scene was just as funny as singing about someone with cancer. He also said that the scene disgraces AIDS and "reinforces homiphoiba."

Gene Copello, an AIDS Institute Director said that Family Guy acted irresponsibly by airing the scene. He said FOX should make an immediate apology to all the people living with HIV or AIDS. "There is nothing comical about a person lying in a hospital bed dying of AIDS or any other disease."

Source: Here

This information came from a NeoPortal
That part was SOO funny and that stuff is usual from Family Guy.


-------------------

A Wizard


quote   quick quote   edit   quick edit   del  searchposts in thread  report
[All dates in (PT) time]Threads List   « Next Newest   Next Oldest »
REPLY TO THIS THREAD   START NEW THREAD


search:
search posts by username:
All Family Guy Forums
Neoseeker Forums » Movies » Television » Family Guy Volume 3 (Season 4) » Did Family Guy Go Too Far?



Jump to another forum:

Powered by neoforums v0.9.8b (equilibrium)
Copyright Neo Era Media, Inc. 1999-2009

neoseeker forum community
Neoseeker.com   |   Forum Rules   |   Forum FAQ   |   Neoseeker Terms of Use   |   Supermods On Duty [ server id: nova ··· elapsed: 0.0877289772]
Affiliated sites:   GameGrep - Football Manager Wiki - Halo Wiki - MGS Wiki - GTA Wiki - Smackdown Wiki - Zelda Wiki - PS2seeker - Xbox seeker - DEVPEN - GFXcess