Which one would you prefer?

The problem with zombie movies is that they are incredibly predictable and nothing ever changes.
Even Dead Rising the game was chock full of stereotypes from George A Romero's movies but that was acceptable because the game can be interacted with and the outcomes and variety of endings mean that it is not immediately obvious.
Even the stupidity of the survivors is, sadly, a stereotype of the zombie genre.

As much as I love zombie movies, it pains me to say that when you have seen one you have pretty much seen them all.

I'd much rather see a sequel to the game.