I reckon that there are some bits that are better in different games. In my opinion, saber duelling is better in JA
a) because you get duel + double sabers with there own moves
b) the attacks are better
c) it looks more like the real duelling(I say real, i meAn in the movies). However, the opponents are a lot easier to beat in JA, even the Jedi Master bots.

The campaign missions were FAR too easy, especially the duelling. Allthough it was a lot of fun 1st time round, it really needs to be made harder.

And finally, as Raijin said, the storyline wasn't that well put together. You run around force pushing and pulling stones and then you go straight out into missions. I was expecting in-depth training (not that i need it, but for the atmosphere) and the chance to duel friends/allies for practice.

BTW Raijin, there is a Sith species out that lets you customise a Sith as your character, have a look at lucasfiles.com

I remember seeing some other body parts out somewhere but can't remember where they are now. I will have another look for them and tell you what I find. And yes the Sith species all look like darth maul except you can change the color and pattern of his face, and of course his clothes.