quote Dragon ZERO

First wolf sonic now sword sonic?

Why don't they change the name from "sonic the Hedgehog" to "The Legend of Sonic."

quote Mario_1

Oh, and for the record, Shadow the Hedgehog was a great game. Fair enough, some people make some valid points against the game, but most people hating on it either haven't played it, or didn't know how to play it right.

quote Barmy Brat

quote Mario_1

Oh, and for the record, Shadow the Hedgehog was a great game. Fair enough, some people make some valid points against the game, but most people hating on it either haven't played it, or didn't know how to play it right.

How many times do you need to be told that there's a difference between a game being "good" and a game being "enjoyable"? Even if you enjoyed playing the game, saying it was "good" is still completely untrue because of the slew of flaws inherent with the game, including (but not limited to) poor aiming mechanics, bland level design coupled with low-poly character models and unappealing texturing, slippery controls and heck - several times while playing, I'd enter a room at a thousand miles an hour and the room itself didn't even load, sending me flying into a black void of nothing. Yes, parts of it were fun, but on no level was it a "good game"; Like it is possible to not enjoy a good game (I don't like anything Final Fantasy, for example), it is also possible to thoroughly enjoy a bad game. It's when you ignore a bad game's many flaws and say it's a "good game" anyway when you're moving away from subjective opinions and into more objective (and incorrect) reasoning.

Also, there's a fairly good reason why people are appalled at "Sonic with a sword" and that is because it is ridiculously out of character. In every game prior to this one, Sonic has represented "nature" while Eggman has represented "machine". Even back in the original game for the Genesis, the game was primarily about nature fighting back against the machines. That's why Eggman used weapons and Sonic used his body; It was a contrast of characters that has worked in every Sonic game from then until now. Giving Sonic a weapon eliminates that distinction. "Nature" is now using man-made weapons to fight back, nullifying the charm and the "message" the games have always been about.

quote Barmy Brat

Thanks for not reading or comprehending the post, kirbyhyrule. Thanks a lot.

quote Barmy Brat

Also, there's a fairly good reason why people are appalled at "Sonic with a sword" and that is because it is ridiculously out of character. In every game prior to this one, Sonic has represented "nature" while Eggman has represented "machine". Even back in the original game for the Genesis, the game was primarily about nature fighting back against the machines. That's why Eggman used weapons and Sonic used his body; It was a contrast of characters that has worked in every Sonic game from then until now. Giving Sonic a weapon eliminates that distinction. "Nature" is now using man-made weapons to fight back, nullifying the charm and the "message" the games have always been about.

quote kirbyhyrule

there is nothing that says "good means that its a fact and enjoyable means you liked it." So you saying that good means he thinks that its a fact is actually just your opinion I guess.