Are you in the transfer market for a new player and find yourself torn between two players of the same position?

Are you a long-term football manager player and can't decide who is better out of Arjen Robben or Cristiano Ronaldo?

Have you always wondered who would win a fight out of Duncan Ferguson and Michael Hughes?

Do you have a bulging squad, consisting of many players in the same position and can't decide who deserves to start?

...If you answered yes to any of those questions, then this is the thread for you!

Think of it like a battle thread between two players. I'm sure you know the drill - when somebody is torn between players and posts here, we help by discussing who the best choice would be.

An example of the sort of thing that could find its way here, would run as follows:

quote GenericMember1234532

Hi. I'm a first time poster. I'm currently managing England in my first season and cannot decide who has the more ability out of Micah Richards and Gary Neville. Can anybody help?

Reserved for use as a index.

looks like a great idea, n1 dave

nice thread

i am approaching the end of season 2 and i need to get rid of one of my wingers.

either nani, silva or malouda.

cheers in advance

personally i would get rid of malouda because i've had great exp with both nani and silva, but why do you need to get rid of one of them? silva and nani are both very good on the right aswell and silva can be a great AMC just behind the strikers

quote marc_k

but why do you need to get rid of one of them

I think Ferguson would win in a fight with Hughes, but Hughes is hard, remember what he did to Robbie Savage.

I would also get rid of Malouda. It may be I'm a bit biased towards Nani and Silva, as I nearly always have them in my squad as a top tier club. But then again, I can't exactly give any negative feedback on Malouda. I have only had him once or twice, and his performances have been excellent for me. But overall, I'd be rid of Malouda. Nani has the advantage of playing on both wings where as Silva is a fantastic playmaker in the AMC spot.

If you want the money then sell Nani/Silva, but if you want to get rid of the old then sell Malouda for less cash than you would get for Nani or Silva.

id reccomend keep malouda mate personally and sell nani. Never really becomes anything special in ANY of my games while Malouda is a solid ocnsistent performer and Silva is a great player and superb playmaker

Hi, I've just started a game as Tottenham and I have 5 different strikers to choose from. Which two would you choose?

- Darren Bent.
- Jermaine Defoe.
- Eddie Johnson.
- Robbie Keane.
- Dimitar Berbatov.

Also, would you make anyone of these strikers a target man? If so, how would you feed him the ball?

Thanks.

Dimitar Berbatov is a goal machine, to be honest. Try to play him with Robbie Keane, because they're different type of player.

Well from the time I orginally posted my query, i've sold Keane for 9 million to Man City. I've just played my first premier league match against Middlesborough with Bent and Defoe up front, I won 5-0 with them scoring 2 a peice.

Thanks for the suggestion anyway, I will take into account what you said about Berbatov and try him out if Defoe or Bent fail.

quote TheGreatOne07

Hi, I've just started a game as Tottenham and I have 5 different strikers to choose from. Which two would you choose?

- Darren Bent.
- Jermaine Defoe.
- Eddie Johnson.
- Robbie Keane.
- Dimitar Berbatov.

Also, would you make anyone of these strikers a target man? If so, how would you feed him the ball?

Thanks.

is this silva we're all talking about the guy from valencia?