quote

Natman4:

8/10
I can see this one. =D I like it, it's very good for a regular banner, but that's the thing. It needs a goodbye message of sorts, as it doesn't look like a footer much.

8/10
....A little plain but still a good header

6/10
I'll give this one a 6/10. I get what the creator of the header is trying to achieve, simplicity. But the output turned out to be to simple that it became plain and boring. And i think the random imaging doesn't work, some images doesn't show.

6/10
Once again, there isn't neccessarily anything wrong with this header but it isn't quite as eye-catching as the other two. Using the image randomizer was a good idea and the overall header is simple and appealing. Though it would have worked better as a footer.

Total: 28

quote

Twin_Master:

7/10
I like this header. It's simple yet effective. The slight alterations each time you refresh was a good take on it, and is good to show the newer members of the forum (like me, just now) who is in the game. To improve, try to make it more of a welcome header, so have a greeting on it.

8/10
....Pretty cool but its looks weird

9/10
For me this is a good header. Yes it is still plain but he managed to get the random imaging works which let's the viewers see a new design with each refresh of the page.
Just needs a "Welcome to the forum text" and i think the logo of dissidia would work better without the shadow.

8/10
It was a great idea to use an image randomizer so you could get all the characters in the header without cluttering it. It's simple, neat and effective. Though maybe some welcome text could have filled in some of the blank space at the bottom?

Total: 32

quote

kuje:

6/10
Good entry here. I like how you have the good people at the top, then the mean nasty people at the bottom. It shows Heaven and Hell. Good one. The text is good, very welcoming. The only problem is that there are just too many characters. It makes the whole piece feel very squished together.

9/10
.....The best one I like

8/10
Actually i like this design. The only problem i see here is that it looks like too compressed because of so much design elements included here.

7/10
I really like the idea of this header- breaking up the heroes and the villains was a great idea. Its just a shame that the size restrictions for the contest have made the image so cluttered. With more space to work with, this could have been a real winner.

Total: 30

quote

beast009:

5/10
I'm not so much of a fan of this. It has good potential, but it feels like you've made a few errors. In parts of the background, some of the purple flickers are cut off. And that mysterious white patch is very distracting. It's a good piece, but I feel like it could have been better.

8/10
....Good also like Natmans' but the quality is little bad

7/10
Pretty good design for me. Just one thing lacking, the design's direction or flow.

6/10
There's nothing neccessarily wrong with this header but it isn't quite as eye-catching as the other two. It also would have been a good idea to use more than FFVIII pictures for a game that has such a diverse bunch of characters.

Total: 26