If you could really choose one of the two to side with in the game, or neither, which would you pick? I would personally side with the Enclave, because although they have that thing going on where essentially everybody with radiation in their body is murdered by drinking the water, they still in a way, kind of have the future planned out better. The Brotherhood of Steel, although wating to save everybody and stuff, still doesn't exactly cure or get rid of the radiated people. The Enclave have the idea of "Kill off everybody to ensure that this doesn't happen again without bombs." While the BoS is thinking "Purify all of the water, so all can live."

While they both have the same idea to a certain degree, you have to remember that there's the one that involves everybody living just fine at the moment, although their bodies are still irradiated with clean water though, or the one that involves everybody irradiated dying, but, ensuring a safer better future... Of course, Vault-Tec promised that also, and all they did was experiment on innocent people who paid good money to get inside the vaults.

But, in the end, they both mean well.

Btw, please note that although after all the things i said about the Enclave possibly being better in ways, remember that if you were to join them, the only people who survived were the Enclave, and the Residents of Vault-101, and even then, due to it being opened before, even though it was assigned not to, it could still have radiation, so it's possibly that the Enclave could be the only survivors. So, you could consider that selfish, or smart. I consider it both.

Neither because they're both armed with ideas and guns... while everyone else is armed with need and hands... and hands do what they know need to be done.

The cities, the resurrection of the world... although FAR off, is always in the hands of the people without rules and government. The only thing both Enclave and BHOS offer are rules which is NOT what people in a ruleless world want to be the only part of. Neither would get far and they serve only to advance their own faction which, over time, will both become corrupted and lose its original goal, just becoming another asshole leadership with guns that take over cities and impose will, rules and lifestyle.

^Win /thread

Wish we could blow up both of their bases in all honesty. But I'm blowing up the Citadel simply because they will both be virtually crippled and beyond repair.

More info here.

WARNING! Plot spoilers for Broken Steel.

I would pick BoS.
Enclave still look evil. BoS just looks intimidating.
Since I became a member in the game anyways.
Even if BoS kicked me out, I would then join the Outcasts instead of the Enclave. Although I do appreciate the Eyebots helping me out

BoS, Enclave just seems like stormtroopers of fallout.

the evil squad if you will.