Computer HardwareXbox GamesGameCubePlaystation 2PSOnePC/Windows GamesGameboy AdvanceDreamcastNintendo 64Gameboy ColorNintendo DSSony PSPXbox 360Nintendo Wii GamesPS3 Games

All Half-Life Forums
Neoseeker Forums » PC Games » Action and Shooters » Portal » The Clone, The Cube and the Construct

REPLY TO THIS THREAD   START NEW THREAD
| Sharemore
Options: Print   subscribe   remove   PM this thread to a friendNeoPM  
subscribe to thread Topic: The Clone, The Cube and the Construct
JoveHack
unwashed heathen
(guest)

IP: Logged
Dec 31, 08 at 9:00pm
The Clone, The Cube and the Construct

The Clone, The Cube and the Construct by game-ism, parts 1 and 2. You'l have to find part 3 on your own.
http://www.game-ism.com/2008/04/13/the-clone-the-cube-and-the-construct-part-1/
http://www.game-ism.com/2008/04/14/the-clone-the-cube-and-the-construct-part-2/

That's part of what makes Portal almost unique. Like Ico and Shadow of the Colossus the player gets to decide on the story. Sure, you can say it's just the standard sadistically insane AI, but where's the fun in that?

Working backward from the empty world Chell finds topside, GlaDOS is trying to train a Chell to survive outside, learning from trial and error. That has led to torturous and frequently fatal treatment of Chell as the most effective training method. This approach has driven GlaDOS insane, because the prime imperative is for Chell to survive.

GlaDOS was training someone who could survive in the current conditions outside. Given the ad hoc nature of the training and the need to use clone androids this seems to mean each previous speciman failed when released to the outside. So GlaDOS has been ramping up the difficulty, and adapting her own interactions with each Chell to find the combination that maximizes survival potential.

Think about that. GlaDOS may have started out friendly and encouraging, but found that just didn't work well enough. GlaDOS has 'raised' and nurtured Chell after Chell, losing all of them. Either on the course or they left and never came back. Her own desires for Chell to succeed have forced GlaDOS to act cruel and sadistic, torturing Chell in the name of survival.

What really clicked was GlaDOS saying that the Weighted Companion Cube would never want to be a burden to Chell. The Companion Cube may have started as a psychological device to help Chell, but GlaDOS is projecting her own feelings onto it as well.

This really fits with Game-ism's theory that GlaDOS is raising this version of Chell to kill her. GlaDOS has had enough of torture as 'tough love.' Maybe the results of previous runs have pointed to the willingness to kill to survive. Just because they didn't survive long term doesn't mean previous Chell's didn't report back as much as possible, but they were too dependent on GlaDOS to survive on their own.

Which is not so say GlaDOS approach would work universally. It's possible Chell is being cloned over and over again, with upgrades, as a control. Like the movie Paycheck, this scenario is being heavily customized to a very specific scenario.

Finally, "This isn't brave, it's murder. What did I ever do to you? You don't even care, do you?"

The first sentence describes GlaDOS training sessions as much as Chell's impending act. The second sentence highlights the ambiguity of the training. Intended to train, it also kills. But GlaDOS has no choice if Chell's ultimate survival is in question. The last sentence is the cry of a rejected mother. A mother rejected in this case by a child specifically trained to do so.

Yes, all of this can be discarded as nonsense. The standard 'Artificial Insanity' scenario fits well enough. It's just interesting that Portal leaves enough clues to point to a different, much deeper, story.
quote   quick quote   edit   quick edit   del  report
Machienzo
Touring the World = 25/11/09 - 13/1/10
(moderator)

Monster Hunter Freedom Unite [PSP]
Sports & Racing [PSP]

wiki staff
monsterhunter



Machienzo's profileMachienzo's neohomeNeoPM MachienzoMachienzo's gallery (102 images)
since: Oct 2006
Jan 23, 09 at 1:39am
re: The Clone, The Cube and the Construct

While there is always the possibility of most of that, if not all of it being true, there can be no way for certain. Hence it being called a "Theory". I find it somewhat, ludicrous. At least from my point of view. It is really up to the audience to accept whatever they see fit and to fill in the gaps by themselves. I have a feeling that not everything will be revealed in the next Portal, which means it will be left up to speculation, just like from the first Portal.


-------------------
quote   quick quote   edit   quick edit   del  searchposts in thread  report
Lorx
moderator

MapleStory [PC]



Lorx's profileNeoPM LorxLorx's gallery (307 images)
total posts: 11678
since: Apr 2006
Jan 23, 09 at 2:10pm
re: The Clone, The Cube and the Construct



The main things we can expect from portal 2 are:
  • The same Dark Humor
  • Portals
  • Puzzles
Those are the things that make the game so great. Especially the humor. We may get some answers, but I doubt there will be a lot.



-------------------
quote   quick quote   edit   quick edit   del  searchposts in thread  report
[All dates in (PT) time]Threads List   « Next Newest   Next Oldest »
REPLY TO THIS THREAD   START NEW THREAD


search:
search posts by username:
All Half-Life Forums
Neoseeker Forums » PC Games » Action and Shooters » Portal » The Clone, The Cube and the Construct



Jump to another forum:

Powered by neoforums v0.9.8b (equilibrium)
Copyright Neo Era Media, Inc. 1999-2009

neoseeker forum community
Neoseeker.com   |   Forum Rules   |   Forum FAQ   |   Neoseeker Terms of Use   |   Supermods On Duty [ server id: ascension ··· elapsed: 0.1456320286]
Affiliated sites:   GameGrep - Football Manager Wiki - Halo Wiki - MGS Wiki - GTA Wiki - Smackdown Wiki - Zelda Wiki - PS2seeker - Xbox seeker - DEVPEN - GFXcess