yea Isabella is better than Gage on a few things but dont count Gage out on Naval Units. Hes better in a Battleship than Isabella cause his sea units are normally stronger plus his indirect bonus...and i like the CO Zone better and i dont use the power a lot...and theres a counter for everyone...

Tabitha is pretty easy to counter on small maps....your gonna expect her to be in a mech, bike or infnatry or a tank at the most....one artillery and a tank of ur own almost gets the job done...a few bikes and shes gone.


This advance wars is more logic than just power cause indirects own if u rush in and the opponent has a wall waiting for u

You're right Isabella is better than Gage. Forsythe can be better too. Here are my ratings and opinions:

Will: 6/10
Brenner: 7.5/10
Lin: 8/10
Isabella: 9/10
Tasha: 6.5/10
Gage: 8.7/10
Forsythe: 9/10
Waylon: 8.2/10
Greyfield: 8.4/10
Penny: 8.8/10
Tabitha: 9.5/10
Caulder: 9.7/10

I think all the Broken COs should be:

Isabella
Gage
Penny
Tabitha
Caulder
Forsythe

That's a lot though lol but if it was a TRIO...

Isabella
Tabitha
Caulder

In my opinion.

Caulder can make some pretty broken city capturers. Considering how many times I remember one of my infantries stuck on a city with 5 HP capturing it, his CO zone would nearly erase that.

But, really, his CO zone drains funds, and thats terrible. Yeah your War tank may be able to take up those artillery/anti-tank hits for a lot of turns, but without a constant stream of more units it just won't work. In my opinion he's only broken on non-FoW maps.

Waylon definitely deserves a bump up Jondog. Seriously though, his COP makes his air units near invincible (if you've used Kanbei's SCOP its kind of like that... or Javiers COP-SCOP with a few C.Towers) Only real threat would be missiles, which only do 40%ish.

Meh, I really don't see how Tabitha is so high. Indirect fire is pretty much the end of her in a unit, and if you put her in an indirect, you lose the strength of getting your power up fast, unless its like a rocket.

Waylon is good too, but Forsythe is better, depends on what kind of map it is. if it is an Air Map and pretty big, Waylon wins. If it is a small map with no Air units, Forsythe wins. Greyfield is very good. Don't forget him.

of course. I thought it would make sense that Waylon would only be good on maps with air units. It goes without saying, they didn't give COs specialized in sea/air anything that effects land.

Tasha would be better on a big map with air units. Defense wouldn't be as noticeable on big maps. On bigger maps its hard to have an AA everywhere, so bombers are more dangerous, and then Tasha can join a bomber and just go around one-shotting stuffs.

I also don't agree with Lin and Brenner being that low. Lin is really great on ground. In my opinion, Brenner > Forsythe. Why? Because Brenner has more DEF, only 2 spaces lower of a CO zone, and has a really awesome, fundless restoring HP, COP. Its debatable I guess, but on small maps, Brenner can just move his units together so they all get the DEF bonus.

Brenner is super with a capital "S". When it comes to air units, Waylon beats Tasha. Waylon's Power increases his Defense stat (*****) a lot. By 50%, not to mention if his units are in his CO Zone, it increases by (***) 30%, if combined, that's a whopping (********) 180% Defense and that's Invincible!!


Every CO are better than each other in different ways. COs that I would hardly ever use are Will and that would have to be it. I'd probably use Waylon a lot.