Well, just like the Roleplaying thread, Deathsythe and I have decided to make a debates on CO's thread. I feel I should list the names of the COs in both forms:

Will - Ed
Brenner - O'Brian
Lin - Lin
Isabella - Catleia
Tasha - Zadia
Gage - Trak
Forsythe - Carter
Waylon - Finn
Greyfield - Sigismundo
Penny - Lili
Tabitha - Larissa
Caulder - Stolos

Once again, depending on how this thread goes, we may chance the list. Here is an example.

1st post:

quote

OK.... Umm... I'll do... Waylon/Finn vs. Penny/Lili! Begin.

2nd post:

quote

I have to vote for Waylon/Finn here... I'm not too keen on Penny because her CO Power is pretty useless... But Waylon's CO Zone has quite some good defensive capabilities, and his CO Power is even more incredible, plus, his CO Zone is at a sweet range. I'll have to go for Waylon/Finn here.

3rd post:

quote

[Someone says something siilar about Penny and Lili]

[a few posts occur... say 2 for Waylon/Finn and 2 for Lili]

final post after a week:

quote

And... It's been a week, so that means the debate is over... and... It's a tie! Waylon/Finn gets 3 points and as does Penny/Lili!

Rules: You should know them, but here are a few ones to remember in this particular thread...

1. Involve no more than 3 COs in 1 debate.
2. Only 1 debate at a time.
3. Debates go on for a week tops. and after that, we have the score, for example, after one week people with meaningful posts voted for will add one point, so say... After one week, the one who called for the debate will say (if not someone else that didn't participate in the debate) Debate is over! Waylon/Finn - 3, Penny/Lili - 2. Waylon/Finn wins!
4. Rebutting is allowed. We don't know how well rebutting will do... we'll see, I'll take it now, but if it gets out of hand and causes too much flaming, I'll have to stop it.
5. You can NOT put your own point in a debate you just made.
6. If you have created a debate, you are the judge.
7. There are no extensions/shortens to the debating time. We will see how we go with this thread, making the debating time more petite or larger... we'll have to see.
8. Regardless if it is a tie, win to 1 CO or loss to another, the debate will end after the week is up.

I suppose I'll let someone else start the debate.
Fightfightfightfightfight FIGHT!!!!

True true, that seems something interesting to see, Deathsythe, seeing as Brenner wasn't able to do much to Greyfield because he, well...



Yet Greyfield DOES have his strongman army and if it weren't for Waylon retiring, the race would be finished easy. I don't even see why or how Greyfield would let Waylon leave. He was such a useful addition to the army, probably the most effective, as well.

Yeah, the main idea is gameplay, but you can fit in a bit of the characteristics.

Come on guys, let's get debating more! Try not to do the characteristics too much, use gameplay stats instead.

I find it interesting how, despite being rivals, they have almost identical CO zones and COPs. Which really doesn't fit Sigismundo, why would he want to protect anyone? He seemed to have the uncaring attitude from what I could gather in Campaign.

Really hard to debate against them, since they almost seem like Isabella/Gage, same area of CO zone, but Sigismundo has greater DEF+ATK bonus. Which means a lot for his naval units. its important for their survival, since they cost a lot more.

So I vote for the Sigismundo, although I hate him, because he can get extremely powerful copters/naval units on command, and his COP is really nice.

Yeah his COP I really actually thought would be Drake's AW1 COP (It did 1 damage to all enemy units) but since Brenner's Andy COP got one up fomr 2-3, maybe Greyfield would damage 2HP to enemies, which would be a little... broken.

"Push further! Don't pull back!" Maybe that represents his COP.

comparing the two COP, i said that greyfield is only effective in long-drawn battle. even on land or air his COP is this great when citys or rig cannot be use to resupply troops.

as for brenner, his the type which can help in any battle, the extra 3 healing is free (i think) and that 3 heal could increase attack power (by 2 shots) plus the defences boosts.

overall if you compare both CO and COP, CO will be brenner for all battle and greyfield for naval battle. as for the COP, both is as good.

Waylon vs Gage brother man

Gage..
After tallying up a weeks total..... Gage wins 1-0!!!
Greyfeild-Forsythe-Caulder-Brenner. All the leaders!
I vote Caulder. To mutch brokenness(even more than Sturm. )

what? Sturm > Caulder any day. Good luck with Sturm's SCOP.

I don't see Isabella anywhere in your post and thus it fails.

Let's all just agree Gage pwns.

Interesting, huh? How a DoR CO could beat a Wars World CO. Because of all the ridiculous buffs & SCOPs.