Just wanted to see what people thought were both good and bad about the game...Mine are

Pros
1)Gameplay is very smooth and realistic
2)Pitches are realistic in time to react and decide on speed and location
3)Camera angles are good
4)Pitch path and ability to recognize between different pitches


Cons
1) Announcers are terrible and think every ball was in the dirt
2) The knee high strike doesn't exist but the strike 3 inches off the plate is called everytime
3) I have a hard time on seeing which player I'm controlling when its a play that can be made by two players but that will probaby just take getting used to
4) A lot of pitches seem to get past the catcher especailly on strike three
5) Some cut scenes for homeruns you dont actually see the homerun ball or where it goes

Don't think though because I have 1 more con than pro doesn't mean I dont like that game...I think the game is real good and definitely the game to get this year..whats everyone elses thoughts??

GAME OF THE YEAR? Hell no. Baseball game of the year, yes. Not even the sport game of the year.
Don't get me wrong its a great game, and I love it but not game of the year.

HAHA lemme rephrase....by no means did i mean video game of the year...i meant baseball game of the year..even more detailed I meant between The Show and 2k8...This game wouldnt come close to video game of the year and as you said I dont think its in the top of the sports games of 07 and most likely 08