Computer HardwareXbox GamesGameCubePlaystation 2PSOnePC/Windows GamesGameboy AdvanceDreamcastNintendo 64Gameboy ColorNintendo DSSony PSPXbox 360Nintendo Wii GamesPS3 Games

All Skies of Arcadia Forums
Neoseeker Forums » GameCube » RPG / Adventure / Strategy » Skies of Arcadia Legends » One Piece influence

REPLY TO THIS THREAD   START NEW THREAD
| Sharemore
Options: Print   subscribe   remove   PM this thread to a friendNeoPM  
subscribe to thread Topic: One Piece influence
SkullKidKazooie
member: postin' posse



SkullKidKazooie's profile
total posts: 559
since: Aug 2005
Jun 11, 06 at 8:25pm
One Piece influence

Has anyone seen the excellent anime that is One Piece? Well I just wanted to know which was made first, SoA or One piece because I think one cleary took inspiration from the other.

quote   quick quote   edit   quick edit   del  searchposts in thread  report
Insanity Prevails
(neocrs)
(moderator)

Site Contributor's Forum
User Reviews Critiques and Help



Insanity Prevails' profileInsanity Prevails' neohomeNeoPM Insanity PrevailsInsanity Prevails' gallery (525 images)
total posts: 14880
neopoints: 7109
GameGrep pts: 412
since: Feb 2003
Jun 11, 06 at 8:36pm
re: One Piece influence

The only connection I see is the pirate theme, which is far too generic to say one was influenced by another.

Characters are different
Plot is different
Abilities are different
Setting is different (One Piece on water, SOA in the sky)

Perhaps if you said why you think they are similar I could better understand your viewpoint.


-------------------
quote   quick quote   edit   quick edit   del  searchposts in thread  report
SkullKidKazooie
member: postin' posse



SkullKidKazooie's profile
total posts: 559
since: Aug 2005
Jun 12, 06 at 4:42pm
re: One Piece influence

Well for a start they both star a cocky young lad who dreams of achieving greatness, they both feature bad tempered red heds, they both try and find crew members, both feature exaggerated characters, like you said they are both based around the theme of pirates, hell they both even feature the main character saving someone about to be executed! A lot of this is just what you get in anime but it doesn't stop the fact that there are similarities. As for the different moves, well I didn't say they were completely identical.
quote   quick quote   edit   quick edit   del  searchposts in thread  report
Insanity Prevails
(neocrs)
(moderator)

Site Contributor's Forum
User Reviews Critiques and Help



Insanity Prevails' profileInsanity Prevails' neohomeNeoPM Insanity PrevailsInsanity Prevails' gallery (525 images)
total posts: 14880
neopoints: 7109
GameGrep pts: 412
since: Feb 2003
Jun 12, 06 at 4:45pm
re: One Piece influence

All you've described is a bunch of clichés. SOAL does fit nicely along the anime/manga style, but consider where Overworks is based. Japan, the home of anime and manga.

It's not just One Piece. It's not just SOAL. Those clichés are present in many anime and RPGs (aside from the pirate theme).


-------------------
quote   quick quote   edit   quick edit   del  searchposts in thread  report
SkullKidKazooie
member: postin' posse



SkullKidKazooie's profile
total posts: 559
since: Aug 2005
Jun 12, 06 at 4:50pm
re: One Piece influence

quote Insanity Prevails
All you've described is a bunch of clichés. SOAL does fit nicely along the anime/manga style, but consider where Overworks is based. Japan, the home of anime and manga.

It's not just One Piece. It's not just SOAL. Those clichés are present in many anime and RPGs (aside from the pirate theme).
I suppose your right. I did say that a lot of this is common in anime and that there are similarities regardless but my original point was that one may have been influenced by the other. As there are so many animes/ manga/ games based around these themes it was probably niave to say that the two are directly related.
quote   quick quote   edit   quick edit   del  searchposts in thread  report
Insanity Prevails
(neocrs)
(moderator)

Site Contributor's Forum
User Reviews Critiques and Help



Insanity Prevails' profileInsanity Prevails' neohomeNeoPM Insanity PrevailsInsanity Prevails' gallery (525 images)
total posts: 14880
neopoints: 7109
GameGrep pts: 412
since: Feb 2003
Jun 13, 06 at 12:10pm
re: One Piece influence

The problem is that developers can't really come up with an original theme anymore. At some point someone's already done it (perhaps with a few rare exceptions).

It's entirely possible Overworks didn't actually try to draw inspiration from anime, but the style they used simply resembled that style.

Of course, that's not to say the possibility that they've watched too much anime and it naturally affected their ideas, but rather that we cannot know for sure as it's really a theme to expect from an Eastern developer.


-------------------
quote   quick quote   edit   quick edit   del  searchposts in thread  report
The Shadowsythe
Grindin' Rollin' Tokin' Smokin'
Resident Neo



The Shadowsythe's profileThe Shadowsythe's neohomeNeoPM The Shadowsythe
total posts: 2852
since: Mar 2004
Jun 13, 06 at 10:06pm
re: One Piece influence

To kill the argument entirely here - SoAL was originally on the dreamcast some time aroun 96/97 - way before One piece was even in the development stages.

Skie's came first - 'nuff said.


-------------------
quote Scott Cee
quote
Is anyone else potentialy pissed?
Of course, I'm Irish.
quote   quick quote   edit   quick edit   del  searchposts in thread  report
[All dates in (PT) time]Threads List   « Next Newest   Next Oldest »
REPLY TO THIS THREAD   START NEW THREAD


search:
search posts by username:
All Skies of Arcadia Forums
Neoseeker Forums » GameCube » RPG / Adventure / Strategy » Skies of Arcadia Legends » One Piece influence



Jump to another forum:

Powered by neoforums v0.9.8b (equilibrium)
Copyright Neo Era Media, Inc. 1999-2009

neoseeker forum community
Neoseeker.com   |   Forum Rules   |   Forum FAQ   |   Neoseeker Terms of Use   |   Supermods On Duty [ server id: nova ··· elapsed: 0.1184821129]
Affiliated sites:   GameGrep - Football Manager Wiki - Halo Wiki - MGS Wiki - GTA Wiki - Smackdown Wiki - Zelda Wiki - PS2seeker - Xbox seeker - DEVPEN - GFXcess