Do you think shadow of the colusses is the best game that has the best first time play through?.... if you get what i mean. I can see how it doesnt have exciting replay value.. but it has the most amazing first time expierence imo

I actually think the game has good replay value. It does after all offer a hard mode, as well as the time trials. Plus the artistic value is enough for me, at least, to experience it more than once.

But actually, I think ICO (and it should be no surpise, since the games have the same atmosphere) has the best 1st time play through. And it's not exactly a game with replay value.

This game is definitely better with replay value, but they should have at least kept your continuing game at the last colossus. I enjoyed beating the last one, and I know I should have saved it on another file, but I didn't think of that at first.

Yeah, this is definatly a game, with a good first timeplay through, but also has good second third and fourth for all the other modes, time, hard, hard time

Best FTE would be the first colossus. I saw it and my eyes shot back into my skull. I was covered in goosebumps because i was so excited to take that !@#$'er down. *Excuuuuse me for getting myself psyched into games* Then when the bastard tries to take me down with his club, misses me, but takes down all the tree's nearby and creates this huge crater in the ground, I'm thinking to myself *Freakin sweet! I get to fight 16 of these colossusesses...-esses*

THen I beat it, and I was like *Sweet, now for hard mode!*