Forum Options:	my.neoforum register members prefs search faq

Original Post

Mar 10, 08 02:40AMWoudo

Now, I have GH3, but I don't a guitar, so i'm forced to use the controller. The problem is, when the notes are less than a mm apart, they're impossible to hit on the controller. The time it takes to pull the trigger in, let it out and pull it in again takes up the time of three of those notes. Because of that, I always get booed off stage halfway through the song.
Is this song entirely possible to beat with a controller?

Around 1:25 is the part where I can't see any possible way a person with a controller could do it. Even if there is an achievement for it.

Thread Recap (last 10 posts from newest to oldest)

Jul 22, 09 02:51AMGeorge2

^ People who like the game.

Jul 09, 09 07:47AMToonami

Who the hell plays this anymore?
Neversoft have released 400 new games since

Jul 04, 09 02:59PMMcilrath

...Still not hard. I FC'd it ages ago

Jul 02, 09 11:15AMHighbury Highs

quote GogetaSSJ4Rules
Erm, dunno why u are complaining, u didnt miss a single note and u do better than i can do on EASY with the GUITAR

It's not hard mate. Try doing it on Expert!

Jul 02, 09 08:00AMRusty193

HAHA.... I beat it...and i never used my star power at all.

:D....same with cliffs of dover.. beat it first time, but having serious trouble with the rest.... i got about 73% of "One" until the fast solo kiked in had it at FC until that moment and .. boo... booo.... messedup reall bad... i'm so gutted.
But yeah i beat it and all it took was a couple of days practising and memorising the notes.. just like real guitar (but nothing like it really lol)

PS.. sorry for double post.. thought last one was long enough .. didn't want to go adding this to it

Jun 30, 09 05:00PMRusty1983

hey.. i was having serious trouble with the notes that are lots and close together, but i worked on it in practice mode and now i can get past this bit still in the green, however it's when i get to the arpeggiated note progression bit at 3.05 that i get boo'd of..... guess my fingers are made for speed and not precicion lol.... it took me about 3 days and with around 25 attemps to beat story of my life on hard.. but after that the rest were easy up until 3's and 7's which just took the p*ss out me... got it done finaly though..and all it took was a bit of practise...i feel your pain... knights of cydonia is a very difficult song and i hope to finnish it soon myself, the last tier is undoubtably the best...cliffs of dover...what a tune and One... well that was challenging on medium, hard will be fun...anyway keep trying... It's called Hard for a reason

Aug 17, 08 11:55AMHBK240

now that i beat it again (2nd time)knights of cydonia on hard on controller seemed to get really easy.... i stayed in green for whole song and only used sp 1ce at the very end

Aug 07, 08 07:58AMHBK240

FINALLY!!!!!!!! i beat One on hard on controller and the devil on hard on controller and i got the buy a guitar already achievement without cheating!!!!

look me up on xbox.com if you don't believe me

Jul 09, 08 06:35AMtimahhh