Neoseeker : News : First Batman: Arkham Asylum review under question

First Batman: Arkham Asylum review under question
Kevin Spiess - Monday, July 27th, 2009 | 2:43PM (PT) 0 Favourites (0)


Is the 96 / 100 score justified?

The blog RAM Raider made a stink the other week: the semi-anonymous gaming journalist blogger stated that Eidos was up to some shenanigans with their new game, Batman: Arkham Asylum. According to RAM Raider, Eidos was only permitting magazine game reviewers to break the review embargo date if the could put Batman on the front cover, and promise a review score over 90%.

The first review came out last week, and it did just that. The magazine was U.K-based publication Games Master. The gave Batman: Arkham Asylum a whopping 96 / 100 score, and the Dark Knight adorns the cover. 

While the vast majority of gamers seem to think Batman: Arkham Asylum looks pretty good, 96 / 100, and calling the game a "masterpiece" seems to have some people suspecting that RAM Raider was dead on when posting on suspicions of Eidos' behavior. 

It does not help Eidos that they were the subject of controversy when Tomb Raider came out last November. For that game, they did not allow any review scores below 8 / 10 to be posted before the game's release date. The P.R company behind this move called it "managing the scores." 

Prior to that, Eidos was suspected of pressuring game journalist Jeff Gertsmann for giving Kane & Lynch: Dead Man a 6/10 score on Gamespot, when the company was spending a great deal advertising on that website.

Whether or not Games Master's 96 / 100 score will prove well-warranted, or suspicously inflated, will have to be determined after more reviewers -- and the gaming public -- have had some time to judge the game for themselves. The sad fact is however, that even if the game is truly a "masterpiece", all of the negativity over the suspected game reviewing foul play will probably lead to doubts over Arkham Aslyum's high review scores for not only Games Master magazine, but for anywhere else.

  • 2 thumbs!
    jdj1976 since Sep 2008 | Jul 28, 09
    sad sad news i for one was already gona get the game the day it came out but if they are up too no good even if the game is 100/100 this makes them look bad in my eyes
  • 0 thumbs!
    Guest | Jul 28, 09
    I subscribe to this magazine and there usually pretty honest and it does look a good game so i'm holding judgment until other reviews are released. All previews i've seen have been positive so I will probably get the game anyway
  • 0 thumbs!
    sonyandnintendorule since Nov 2007 | Jul 28, 09
    yeah the Ads for this game werent like most ads 4 crap games there were small snippets but each of those snippets looked damn fine
    deffinitely gonna rent this one maybe buy if its got some nice long 20+ hour gameplay
  • 0 thumbs!
    George2 since Jan 2007 | Jul 28, 09
    I've got that issue, I was quite surprised that it got 96/100, maybe I should try it.
  • 0 thumbs!
    solo | Aug 10, 09
    I played ther demo on the PS3 over the weekend, downloaded from playstation store, and all I can say is going on the demo they should of given it 98/100 it really is that impressive, if you like your batman they way it should be and as DC comics reated it, and not like the movies then you are in for a real treat!!. If you have not pre-ordered it to secure a copy alot of people will be disapointed come release day in 2 weeks time!!!
  • -2 thumbs!
    chris | Aug 12, 09
    at the end of the day, who cares? the game is great, and it will be a GOTY candidate.
  • 1 thumbs!
    kspiess since Jun 2007 | Aug 12, 09
    Who cares? Well I do. I would rather have reviews based on reviewers' opinions, instead of his questionable relationship to the company involved.
    Last edited by kspiess :: Aug 12, 09
  • 1 thumbs!
    kspiess since Jun 2007 | Aug 12, 09
    The whole point of review is giving honest feedback on something, to let your readers know whether or not it is worth buying. I'm kind of alarmed that you think it's fine that companies have more influence on a review score than the game itself. If you think that this is the case, then why do you even read reviews at all?
  • 1 thumbs!
    Andy | Aug 23, 09
    To be honest I don't really pay much attention to reviews of games, as everyone has their own taste and expectations of games. The best way to judge if you like a game is to play demos, rent the game when it comes out even, then buy it if you like it. Then it makes the whole argument of whether a review is honest or "bought" by a comapny pointless. At the end of the day games are there to enjoy, so why waste time and energy on this subject?
  • 0 thumbs!
    chautemoc since Mar 2008 | Aug 23, 09
    A more appropriate question given that argument would be: why review games at all? But so long as we do, it's important to discuss these matters.
  • 1 thumbs!
    MrGrimm since Mar 2008 | Aug 23, 09
    Whatever gain they may get from coercing reviewers is probably going to be counteracted by the bad reputation they gain from doing so.
  • 0 thumbs!
    Dr Killfrenzy since Aug 2009 | Aug 26, 09
    don't count on it MrGrimm...Eidos did this sort of thing before (the Eidos-Gamespot soap opera) and they still sell a lot of games. Bad reputation for coercing reviewers? there are just too little people like you reading news on sites like neoseeker...the majority of the potential buyers do not read such news, but only see a nifty looking games mag with batman on the cover and then quickly get to the page where they can see the review score.
  • 0 thumbs!
    Dr Killfrenzy since Aug 2009 | Aug 26, 09
    @Chris: how can you know if the game is gonna be great before buying/renting/borrowing the game if you cannot trust the reviews?
    This kind of behavior by Eidos only gives software pirates a good reason to crack the game, so they can tell the world they did it so people can honestly make up their mind about a certain game before buying it...
  • 0 thumbs!
    kspiess since Jun 2007 | Aug 26, 09
    Well , in the end, it looks like Batman is a big winner regardless. Judging by all the reviews now, it's looking like a Game of the Year possibility .
  • 0 thumbs!
    Dr Killfrenzy since Aug 2009 | Aug 26, 09
    Not that I am a supporter of software piracy...
  • 0 thumbs!
    chautemoc since Mar 2008 | Aug 26, 09
    The launch trailer has already shown one GOTY award, which I don't understand...
  • 0 thumbs!
    chautemoc since Mar 2008 | Aug 26, 09
    quote Dr Killfrenzy
    This kind of behavior by Eidos only gives software pirates a good reason to crack the game, so they can tell the world they did it so people can honestly make up their mind about a certain game before buying it...
    I don't see how they're related. Anyway that's what demos are for.
  • 0 thumbs!
    Jack Shit | Aug 26, 09
    While it's troubling to have a thing like "review inflation" be an issue in the market, it is not a secret practice among developers and gamer review boards. It's a process folks, called Marketing!! Hype a game up, give a good review on your site, reep the rewards of revenue from developers who want you to review their games and consumers wh'll buy your mag to know more about the game. It's a system of companies cratching each others backs folks.. not rocket science..it's buisness. A fine example of such false hype is from Microsoft and Lionhead with their ever popular over hyped game Fable and Fable 2. The reviews changed from Peter Molnahuex being the virtual Rpg messiah to being it's venomous Anti-christ of false promises directly after the christmas season. In conclusion, Edios (if guilty) hasn't done what everyone else hasn't already done a million times before. The simple solution to this kind of marketing is to stop listening or reading reviews and experence the games yourselves by renting, demoing, or buying the game on your own. I personally think Batman Arkham Asylum is well deserving of its hype, you may feel differently. Think for yourselves people.
- This news story is archived and is closed to new comments now -

Hardware Newsletter:
Email:



Compare Prices

Motherboards
Abit
ASUS
Gigabyte
MSI
eVGA
Intel
Tyan
More...

Processors
AMD
Intel
More...

Memory
DDR
DDR2
DDR3
More...

Video Cards
ATI
eVGA
XFX
BFG
Sapphire
More...

search for lowest prices
(0.0850/mc/nova)